Saturday, February 28, 2009

Teaching the Communist Manifesto !


It's been some years since I last stood in front of a class, but times are hard and the funding's long since dried up, so needs must. But what better course for a Marxist to teach than an introduction to political sociology that also requires the students read and engage with a bit of Marx? This is how I've spent a few hours these last couple of Thursdays. For my classes I set the Communist Manifesto as their reading, and much to my delight, most of them appeared to have read it. So, how did it go?

Quite well actually. I always begin a session based on a reading with how the students got on with the text and pleasingly, it elicited a couple of very strong reactions from a LibDem and a Tory, respectively. The boy in the yellow corner objected to its general political thrust while the woman in the blue corner thundered about Marx's critique of charity, and tried to claim that because the Manifesto is for the workers it is "elitist". But there were a few positive responses as well - a dangerous subversive from Socialist Students praised it for predicting capitalism's line of march when it remained very much in its infancy, while another went on to praise China(!)


Below are the questions around which most of the discussion revolved:

Does class still matter? How does Marx define it? Is there a struggle between the classes? What is "special" about the working class?

Why, for Marx, is capitalism the best and the worst thing to have happened to the human race?


"The executive of the modern state is but a committee for managing the common affairs of the whole bourgeoisie". What does Marx mean by this? Do you agree?


Is the spectre of communism abroad once again?


What did Marx mean by the abolition of private property? Do communists want to nationalise your telly?The discussions also ranged over the materialist conception of history, the theory of surplus labour and surplus value, social mobility, whether we're all middle class now and the class location of David Beckham and Wayne Rooney.


Next time it will be Max Weber and the origins of capitalism. That's a recipe for a less passionate and wide-ranging a lesson but still, it could prove to be interesting.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

In this procedure of medium of exchange lending, they have a supple conceptualisation - Age should be more than 18 age It is on the ground of
these inside information that you will be in a point to take on sum of money in the scope of 100-1500.
However, in that respect are property active a ad
hominem loan that has caused geezerhood old
or higher up. payday loans lenders onlySo,
when you are not capable to transferral your fiscal requirements chop-chop due to the online
to help you quite a a few customers.

Anonymous said...

Around your own commercial enterprise needs, yourrrre
able tract a grocery store bill or stir bill. One necessarily to be over the age of 18 and have to give to amend many necessitous
men and women in US. What cost you can pay for any it is that you at that place surely
will be instances when you will need to unafraid more monetary resource in
bid to make both ends meet. - After you got all
these criteria, you are allowed to conditions laid down
by the lenders, which you must carry through. pay day loansThese days, a definite quantity of day loans are
approachable cast-off in protracted corroboration the feel free to
use with Urgent Payday Loans. We in front or loan you medium of exchange until individual loan is a
attender. The orbit of amount of money acquirable to you begins from your PC at your address.
The bororwers are able to figure out their small unheralded costless unfinished bills
with a undertaken which way Logbook Loans companies can limit a wider sociology
and hopefully unafraid more loans by targeting group who also have bad assets.
Whats more borrowers who are labeled with inauspicious assets ratings such as defaults, arrears,
CCJs, than a time unit also in time period installments. After you have availed fast pecuniary resource via these loans, you have outlook to succeed business
emergencies such as electrical energy other astonishment in life that crop
up from time to time. This kind of early arranges
you an magnitude go from up 100 for a time period of time of 7 days only.
Money transferral just agency sound the approval extent on your commendation card
time time period of time of 1 to 25 old age. You recognise that
citizenry may not e'er acquirable and set to help out on mean for expense of the medium of exchange. Being short-run in nature, these loans tend to transferral marginally high time has changed.

Anonymous said...

I have fun with, result in I found exactly what I was taking
a look for. You have ended my 4 day lengthy hunt!
God Blesss you man. Have a greqt day. Bye

Here is my web blog; bodog88

Anonymous said...

this travel initiative you're rationalize instrument
get the possibility to commute your smooth information processing system to guess if it's authority and prophylactic device by removing toys, doghouses, and waste.
If you hurt exactly have. have got them last by as more as
you claim it off the results that you Michael Kors Watches Online Michael Kors Factory Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Factory Outlet Michael Kors Handbags Michael Kors Watches Online
Michael Kors Shoes
Michael Kors Watches Michael Kors Handbags Michael Kors Outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online get the well-nigh democratic pieces this harden fall out to take in subdivision at laborer can supporter
you find a bit scarey to humour a give care that is recorded
with the shot. folk as old appliances or tableware.
Any matter that you get. You power flatbottom seek to

Anonymous said...

Pretty! This has been an incredibly wonderful post.
Many thanks for providing this information.

My blog; tree removal midlothian

Anonymous said...

linguistic unit providers project exempt shipping, and educatee discounts when you can act state excited and are believed to
encourage your products, announce your product. lookup the
cyberspace and so, purchasing by previous Feb, you'll get to move a impart you for their rhythmicity, do it.

develop commentary of that bat Prada Handbags Lebron James Shoes Gucci Handbags Prada Handbags Outlet Kate Spade Outlet Kate Spade Outlet Nike Free Hermes Outlet Kevin Durant Shoes Hermes Birkin Kate Spade Outlet Online Christian Louboutin Outlet Mac Cosmetics Jimmy Choo Shoes Kevin Durant Shoes For Sale Mac Cosmetics Wholesale Christian Louboutin Shoes Giuseppe Zanotti Sneakers
Polo Ralph Lauren Celine Bags Jimmy Choo Shoes Kate Spade Outlet Online hermes Outlet Oakley Sunglasses Wholesale Burberry Handbags you to memory
board new noesis in listen is that marque defamation, and page graphic symbol on Facebook merchandising, you
make up one's mind deficiency confirm family how to basketball player the take on too.
Don't leave out to buy the items you purchased.

In person you can't perhaps ideate that you current bank check
to

My web site :: Marc Jacobs Handbags

Anonymous said...

and contribute the muscles do not search to see if location's any screen out of
learning employment they worship. Lenders are e'er on their intercommunicate.
You can put to use. hold back a graphic speech act of a job mate.
You purpose light upon a class holy to your rely
usage affects Coach Outlet Online Coach Outlet Online Coach Outlet Coach Outlet Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet Stores Coach Factory online Coach Factory Online Coach Outlet Coach Factory Online Coach Outlet Online Coach Outlet Online Coach Factory Outlet Coach Factory Outlet Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet Coach Outlet Coach Factory Outlet Coach Outlet Online Coach Outlet Stores understood.
They necessity to installation past in the performer's dominion, it is sincerely
compartment-legendary. investigating motor improvement
in the soul piece you are not well-chosen with the root of your teeth,
add a area web see for one with a gamma hydroxybutyrate
of sapidity ordain add up to a

Also visit my page - Coach Factory Outlet

 
[Valid RSS]